Memish
Get the app
Meaning · examples · origin

Always Has Been meme

The Always Has Been meme shows one astronaut discovering a surprising truth while a second astronaut confirms it was true all along. The usual exchange is “Wait, it’s all X?” followed by “Always has been.”

An astronaut looks at Earth while a second astronaut behind them holds a pistol.WAIT, IT’S ALL PROCRASTINATION?ALWAYS HAS BEEN.
Download template

What does it mean?

The first astronaut represents the person who has just worked something out. The second already knows. The joke depends on the discovery feeling enormous to the first person even though everyone else seems to have accepted it ages ago.

The original space setting makes a very ordinary realization look absurdly dramatic. Your calendar can become the planet, a friend’s familiar habit can become the revelation, and the short answer can turn a small observation into a grand explanation of everything.

The Memish translation

“You just noticed? This has been the situation the entire time.”

How the format works

  1. Give the first astronaut a discovery beginning with “Wait, it’s all…” or a similarly surprised question.
  2. Keep “Always has been” as the second astronaut’s response so the reveal has its familiar rhythm.
  3. If you label the Earth or another object, use that label to support the discovery rather than introducing a second joke.

Caption examples for your group chat

Original Memish examples. Borrow the structure and make the situation your own.

01The walking route

“Wait, every walk ends at the bakery?”

“Always has been.”

The revelation is a pattern that your walking companion already understands.

02The study group

“Wait, this study chat is mostly meme recommendations?”

“Always has been.”

Use a real shared habit so you do not need a paragraph of setup.

03The weekend calendar

“Wait, all our plans are just different ways to get snacks?”

“Always has been.”

A small truth becomes funnier when the image treats it as a discovery about the universe.

When to use it

Use it when you finally recognize a pattern your friends already know: every outing includes a bakery stop, the study chat mostly contains memes, or a supposedly new habit has been happening for years. A shared reference makes the short exchange land immediately.

When another reaction fits

If the joke is about a new development, the reply will be confusing because this format says the truth was there all along. For an unexpected consequence, Surprised Pikachu fits better. For a promising announcement that becomes worrying, try Anakin and Padmé.

Where did it come from?

The format developed through internet drawings and edits of two astronauts looking at Earth. Know Your Meme documents early versions before the familiar realistic astronaut composite spread widely in 2020. “Wait, it’s all Ohio?” is one well-known variation. The template’s original image-maker remains unverified in our image credit; the caption scenarios here are Memish originals.

Image credit: Internet astronaut composite; original image-maker unverified.

Make it your inside joke.

Make a meme from a photo, template, or GIF, then send it to a friend in Memish. Free on iPhone and Android.

Free to download.