Memish
Get the app
Meaning · examples · origin

American Chopper Argument meme

The American Chopper Argument meme uses five stills of Paul Teutul Sr. and Paul Teutul Jr. in an increasingly heated argument. New captions give the pair a different debate, often about something far too small to justify the anger. Each reply challenges the previous one while the scene supplies the rising intensity.

Five panels of Paul Teutul Sr. and Jr. arguing, including a chair being thrown.CEREAL IS SOUP!SOUP IS HOT!GAZPACHO!CEREAL IS BREAKFAST!SO IS SOUP IF YOU BELIEVE!
Download template

What does it mean?

Treat the panels as a conversation: one speaker takes the first, third, and fifth turns, and the other takes the second and fourth. The second turn objects to the first; the third answers that objection. The joke gets stronger when both sides can make a point, even as their reactions become absurdly large.

A tiny subject gives the anger a clear contrast. Cake size, the lift, or when to leave can support a real chain of counterarguments without needing a serious dispute. Five unrelated shouted opinions miss that chain. The last panel should answer the fourth and end on a stubborn conclusion or a ridiculous compromise.

The Memish translation

“We have strong opinions and absolutely no stakes.”

How the format works

  1. Choose one small disagreement and write a short opening claim for the top panel.
  2. Alternate the two speakers for five turns. Make each new line respond directly to the point immediately above it.
  3. Use very short words and sentences so each reply fits its narrow panel. Finish with the first speaker's exaggerated answer rather than adding a sixth caption.

Caption examples for your group chat

Original Memish examples. Borrow the structure and make the situation your own.

01The lift debate

TAKE THE LIFT!

IT IS ONE FLOOR!

WE HAVE SIX BAGS!

TAKE TWO EACH!

THERE ARE TWO OF US!

Every reply addresses the last one, ending with the arithmetic that the stair plan forgot.

02The cake order

WE NEED A BIG CAKE!

THERE ARE FOUR OF US!

WE CAN SAVE SOME!

THE FRIDGE IS FULL!

THEN WE NEED FORKS!

A storage objection turns the plan to save cake into a stubborn plan to eat it all now.

03The two-minute departure

LEAVE AT EIGHT!

IT STARTS AT EIGHT!

IT IS NEXT DOOR!

WE STILL NEED SHOES!

THEN WEAR SLIPPERS!

The nearby cinema becomes an excuse to leave late, and footwear becomes the final concession.

When to use it

Use it to replay an affectionate group-chat debate about food, travel shortcuts, games, or some other low-stakes rule everyone keeps defending. It works especially well when friends can recognize the reasoning on both sides and enjoy the gap between the tiny question and the enormous reaction.

When another reaction fits

A disagreement that needs lots of background will be cramped in these panels. A real unresolved fight may also give the angry faces more weight than the joke needs. Anakin and Padmé is better for a short exchange with a realization, while Woman Yelling at a Cat suits two clashing perspectives without five linked arguments.

Where did it come from?

The stills come from an American Chopper dispute about Paul Teutul Jr.'s timekeeping. Know Your Meme dates the source episode, “NHL Bike B2 Bomber Bike,” to April 9, 2009, and documents the format's wider spread in March 2018. Discovery published a video of the cast discussing the meme in May 2018. These five-line debates are original Memish captions, rather than dialogue from the television argument.

Image credit: Discovery / American Chopper.

Make it your inside joke.

Make a meme from a photo, template, or GIF, then send it to a friend in Memish. Free on iPhone and Android.

Free to download.